| Tom Ahern (Class of 1963) | Fencing |
| |
| Bob Babb (Class of 1977) | Coach |
| Monika Bay (Class of 1982) | Swimming |
| Andy Bernstein (Class of 1990) | Baseball |
| Tom Biddison (Class of 1928) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Jon Blank (Class of 1981) | Swimming |
| Pete Blohm (Class of 1987) | Baseball |
| Vern Booth (Class of 1924) | Track and Field |
| Craig Brooks (Class of 1986) | Baseball |
| Emil "Buzzy" Budnitz (Class of 1953) | Soccer, Lacrosse, Basketball |
| Lloyd Bunting (Class of 1950) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Luke Busby (Class of 1994) | Basketball |
| |
| Mark Campbell (Class of 1986) | Baseball, Football |
| Beth Cariello Fifer (Class of 1994) | Field Hockey, Lacrosse |
| Henry Ciccarone (Class of 1962) | Football, Lacrosse, Coach |
| Louis Clarke (Class of 1922) | Track and Field |
| Alice Collins Margraff (Class of 1989) | Lacrosse, Field Hockey, Squash |
| Tim Collins (Class of 1980) | Swimming |
| Frank Comfort | Coach |
| Jeff Cook (Class of 1982) | Lacrosse |
| Paul Cordts (Class of 1980) | Fencing |
| Joe Cowan (Class of 1969) | Football, Lacrosse |
| |
| John DeTommaso (Class of 1986) | Lacrosse |
| Mike DiCio (Class of 1979) | Swimming & Diving |
| Amy Dodrill (Class of 1995) | Basketball |
| Del Dressel (Class of 1986) | Lacrosse |
| |
| Andy Enfield (Class of 1991) | Basketball |
| |
| Jeff Fang (Class of 1992) | Baseball |
| Mike Federico (Class of 1980) | Lacrosse |
| Wilson Fewster (Class of 1950) | Coach, Lacrosse, Football |
| Tom Finegan (Class of 1988) | Football, Baseball |
| |
| Frank Gangemi (Class of 1991) | Football |
| Jay Gangemi (Class of 1992) | Basketball |
| Oscar Garcia-Rivera (Class of 1960) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Andy Goldberg (Class of 1986) | Fencing |
| Mark Greenberg (Class of 1980) | Lacrosse |
| Gerry Greenfield (Class of 1974) | Track & Field |
| Lorne Guild (Class of 1932) | Men's Lacrosse, Football |
| |
| Cindy Harper Covington (Class of 1988) | Basketball, Track |
| Kathy Hart (Class of 1989) | Lacrosse, Field Hockey, Squash |
| Mark Horning (Class of 1975) | Swimming |
| |
| Bill Jews (Class of 1974) | Basketball |
| |
| Hank Kaestner (Class of 1967) | Lacrosse |
| Joe Kail (Class of 1994) | Baseball |
| Loree Keleher (Class of 1978) | Fencing |
| Jim Kelley (Class of 1961) | Football, Wrestling |
| Donaldson Kelly (Class of 1934) | Lacrosse, Basketball, Football |
| Bill Kinling (Class of 1950) | Soccer |
| Heather Klink (Class of 1988) | Lacrosse, Field Hockey |
| Sylke Knuppel (Class of 1993) | Basketball, Track, Soccer |
| Lou Koerber (Class of 1949) | Football, Baseball |
| Rick Kowalchuk (Class of 1974) | Lacrosse, Football |
| |
| Patty Lagator Knott (Class of 1990) | Lacrosse |
| John Lang (Class of 1928) | Lacrosse, Basketball, Football |
| Millard T. Lang (Class of 1934) | Soccer, Lacrosse |
| Mike Leonhardt (Class of 1984) | Swimming |
| |
| C. Gardner Mallonee (Class of 1928) | Football, Lacrosse, Coach |
| Simeon Margolis (Class of 1953) | Basketball, Baseball |
| Jim Margraff (Class of 1982) | Football |
| Stu Markley (Class of 1994) | Football |
| Les Matthews (Class of 1973) | Lacrosse, Football |
| Bill Milne (Class of 1974) | Swimming |
| Steve Mitchell (Class of 1987) | Lacrosse, Basketball, Football |
| Doug Morgan (Class of 1981) | Swimming |
| William "Kelso" Morrill, Sr. (Class of 1927) | Coach |
| William "Bill" Morrill, Jr. (Class of 1959) | Lacrosse |
| |
| Dick Oles (Class of 1968) | Coach, Fencing |
| Michael O'Neill (Class of 1978) | Lacrosse |
| |
| Frank Parreira (Class of 1980) | Baseball |
| Dave Pietramala (Class of 1989) | Lacrosse |
| Dave Psenicska (Class of 1988) | Baseball |
| |
| Larry Quinn (Class of 1985) | Lacrosse |
| |
| Dawn Richards Tolbert (Class of 1985) | Basketball |
| John Robinson (Class of 1992) | Cross Country, Track |
| Juliane Rolapp Huguely (Class of 1991) | Basketball |
| Lou Ruland (Class of 1955) | Wrestling, Lacrosse |
| |
| Rebecca Savage Keller (Class of 1994) | Lacrosse, Soccer, Squash |
| "Father" Bill Schmeisser (Class of 1902) | Coach, Lacrosse |
| Austin "Jerry" Schmidt (Class of 1962) | Lacrosse, Football |
| Jerome Schnydman (Class of 1967) | Lacrosse |
| Bob Scott (Class of 1952) | Coach, Administrator |
| Dr. G. Wilson Shaffer (Class of 1924) | Administrator |
| Julie Siegrist (Class of 1990) | Lacrosse, Field Hockey |
| Bill Smiddy (Class of 1980) | Swimming |
| Fred Smith (Class of 1950) | Lacrosse, Wrestling, Coach |
| Eric Steidinger (Class of 1994) | Swimming |
| Bill Stromberg (Class of 1982) | Football, Baseball |
| |
| Jack Thomas (Class of 1974) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Harry Tighe (Class of 1950) | Soccer, Track and Field, Wrestling |
| John Tolson (Class of 1941) | Lacrosse |
| Brooke Tunstall (Class of 1948) | Lacrosse |
| Doug Turnbull, Jr. (Class of 1925) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Jack Turnbull (Class of 1932) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Marshall Turner | Administrator |
| |
| Mickey Webster (Class of 1959) | Lacrosse |
| Paul Weiss (Class of 1970) | Football, Lacrosse |
| Brian Wood (Class of 1987) | Lacrosse |
| |
| Church Yearley (Class of 1934) | Lacrosse, Football, Basketball |
